A Guide to Rent Withholding: How It Works and What You Should Know

If a landlord doesn’t keep your rental unit safe and livable, some states allow you to stop paying rent until the issues are fixed.

This legal process is called “rent withholding”. However, it comes with rules and steps that tenants need to follow carefully. Here’s what you need to know:
 

What Is Rent Withholding?

Rent withholding isn’t as simple as refusing to pay rent outright. In many states, you’re required to put the withheld rent into a special account managed by a court, a neutral third party, or a housing authority until the landlord fixes the problem.

In states where this setup doesn’t exist, you withhold rent at your own risk. If the landlord tries to evict you for not paying, you can defend yourself in court by proving the rental was not livable. However, if the court sides with the landlord, you might lose the case and face eviction.
 

When Can Rent Withholding Be Used?

Rent withholding is allowed only in states that permit it by law. If your state doesn’t allow it, you may need to explore other options, such as using a “repair-and-deduct” method.

Even in states that permit rent withholding, certain conditions must be met. For example:
 

• The Issue Must Be Serious: The problem must make your rental unsafe or uninhabitable.
• It Can’t Be Your Fault: The damage or problem can’t be caused by you, a roommate, or a guest.
• You’re Following Your Lease Agreement: You must be up-to-date on rent payments and in compliance with your lease.
• You Follow Legal Steps: You need to follow the rules in your state for withholding rent.

Some states also limit how much rent you can withhold or how often you’re allowed to do it. For example, you may not be able to withhold rent multiple times within the same year.
 

How Do You Withhold Rent?

If you decide to withhold rent, here’s a step-by-step guide to help you:

1. Learn Your State's Law: Research your state and local laws to confirm rent withholding is allowed. Find out:

• What kinds of problems justify withholding rent.
• Whether you have to give the landlord a deadline to fix the issue.
• If you need to deposit the withheld rent into a special account or escrow.

2. Notify Your Landlord: Write a letter to your landlord explaining the problem and your intention to withhold rent. Include a reference to the law that allows rent withholding and give the landlord a reasonable deadline to address the problem. Send the letter via certified mail to ensure there’s proof the landlord received it.

3. Collect Evidence: If the landlord doesn’t fix the issue, gather proof to support your case. Take clear photos of the problem, keep copies of all communications, and get a signed report from a professional (such as a contractor) explaining the issue and estimating repair costs.

4. Follow Up: If your landlord doesn’t respond, send another letter with a shorter deadline, such as 48 hours or whatever feels reasonable given the situation.

5. File Court Documents (if required): In some states, you may need permission from a court to withhold rent. You can get the necessary forms and instructions from local courts or housing agencies.

6. Deposit Rent in Escrow: In many cases, you’re required to deposit the withheld rent into a special account, such as one run by a court or a local housing authority. Even if state law doesn’t require this, it’s a good idea to deposit the rent into a neutral account. This shows that you are withholding rent to fix the problem, not just to avoid payment.
 

What Happens to Withheld Rent?

If your rent is held by a court or housing authority, the money might be used to pay for repairs. In some cases, you only pay part of your rent to the landlord while the problem is being fixed.

When the rental is declared safe and livable by housing authorities or the court, any remaining rent is given back to the landlord—minus any fees from court or inspections.

If your state doesn’t require rent to be escrowed (held in a neutral account), you’ll need to negotiate with your landlord once the repairs are complete. The landlord will likely expect full payment of the withheld rent. If you refuse to pay, they may file an eviction lawsuit for not paying rent.
 

What If Repairs Take a Long Time?

If repairs aren’t done for months, you may feel it’s unfair to pay full rent for the time you lived with the problem.

One option is to request a reduction in rent for the time your rental was unlivable. This is called “rent abatement” and can sometimes be granted by courts or through negotiations with landlords.
 

Final Thoughts

Rent withholding is a legal tool to protect tenants when landlords fail to make necessary repairs. However, it’s important to follow the rules carefully and understand what your state law allows.

If done incorrectly, withholding rent could lead to eviction. Make sure you communicate clearly, document everything, and handle withheld rent responsibly.

-

Find out if you're eligible for housing support here!